Comments on: Top Gear Versus Fifth Gear: Which British Car Show Is Better? http://www.ededition.com/top-gear-versus-fifth-gear-which-british-car-show-is-better/ 100% of your daily recommended intake of awesome Thu, 09 Feb 2012 07:47:49 +0000 http://wordpress.org/?v=2.9.2 hourly 1 By: Josh http://www.ededition.com/top-gear-versus-fifth-gear-which-british-car-show-is-better/comment-page-3/#comment-242473 Josh Thu, 19 Jan 2012 03:11:53 +0000 http://www.ededition.com/top-gear-versus-fifth-gear-which-british-car-show-is-better/#comment-242473 Michael Schumacher is not The Stig. It's only when Ferrari don't trust the real Stig to test their car, like the Ferrari Enzo FXX. Michael Schumacher is not The Stig. It’s only when Ferrari don’t trust the real Stig to test their car, like the Ferrari Enzo FXX.

]]> By: Zakk http://www.ededition.com/top-gear-versus-fifth-gear-which-british-car-show-is-better/comment-page-3/#comment-242470 Zakk Mon, 16 Jan 2012 07:25:08 +0000 http://www.ededition.com/top-gear-versus-fifth-gear-which-british-car-show-is-better/#comment-242470 Can't factor in the Stig??? Blasphemy!!! Don't know who he is?? Balderdash!! The black stick was Perry McCarthy. The first white Stig was Ben Collins. For 7 years. I think both of their credentials are sufficient to trump Fifth Gear by a mile. And Tiff the Stig?? No. He was Emergency Stig once. (In the USA Road Trip (aired 21 December 2010), Tiff Needell was brought in as an 'Emergency Stig' to train Danny Boyle on the track.http://www.mirror.co.uk/celebs/tv/2010/12/17/top-gear-s-new-stig-is-tiff-needell-115875-22788744/) Please. Can’t factor in the Stig??? Blasphemy!!! Don’t know who he is?? Balderdash!! The black stick was Perry McCarthy. The first white Stig was Ben Collins. For 7 years. I think both of their credentials are sufficient to trump Fifth Gear by a mile.

And Tiff the Stig?? No. He was Emergency Stig once. (In the USA Road Trip (aired 21 December 2010), Tiff Needell was brought in as an ‘Emergency Stig’ to train Danny Boyle on the track.http://www.mirror.co.uk/celebs/tv/2010/12/17/top-gear-s-new-stig-is-tiff-needell-115875-22788744/)

Please.

]]> By: Luke http://www.ededition.com/top-gear-versus-fifth-gear-which-british-car-show-is-better/comment-page-3/#comment-242456 Luke Fri, 06 Jan 2012 10:18:48 +0000 http://www.ededition.com/top-gear-versus-fifth-gear-which-british-car-show-is-better/#comment-242456 The Stig is not Schumacher. The Stig is not Schumacher.

]]> By: peter http://www.ededition.com/top-gear-versus-fifth-gear-which-british-car-show-is-better/comment-page-3/#comment-242439 peter Tue, 27 Dec 2011 19:45:56 +0000 http://www.ededition.com/top-gear-versus-fifth-gear-which-british-car-show-is-better/#comment-242439 how can you say that ooh i like cars cars are boring get over it 5th gear can kiss my ass no one likes you 5th gear well no self respecting person would subject them selves to boring shit how can you say that ooh i like cars cars are boring get over it 5th gear can kiss my ass no one likes you 5th gear well no self respecting person would subject them selves to boring shit

]]> By: chase berecin http://www.ededition.com/top-gear-versus-fifth-gear-which-british-car-show-is-better/comment-page-3/#comment-242425 chase berecin Tue, 20 Dec 2011 02:13:01 +0000 http://www.ededition.com/top-gear-versus-fifth-gear-which-british-car-show-is-better/#comment-242425 Top gear for life. Love bbca Top gear for life. Love bbca

]]> By: mo http://www.ededition.com/top-gear-versus-fifth-gear-which-british-car-show-is-better/comment-page-3/#comment-242337 mo Mon, 31 Oct 2011 23:21:25 +0000 http://www.ededition.com/top-gear-versus-fifth-gear-which-british-car-show-is-better/#comment-242337 Fifth Gear is the best !!! Fifth Gear is the best !!!

]]> By: Stewart http://www.ededition.com/top-gear-versus-fifth-gear-which-british-car-show-is-better/comment-page-3/#comment-242336 Stewart Mon, 31 Oct 2011 09:38:57 +0000 http://www.ededition.com/top-gear-versus-fifth-gear-which-british-car-show-is-better/#comment-242336 I for many years was a big fan of Top Gear, enjoying Clarkson literary talent and Hammond's book following his crash. Shame about what's him name, the other one. But unfortunately it's deteriorated into a programme for 5 year olds, embarrassingly pathetic and zero content if you want intelligent information about cars. In fact the comment above says it all, "entertaining", yep like Coronation Street. If that's want you want, good for you but I think the intelligent amongst us want an awful lot more. I for many years was a big fan of Top Gear, enjoying Clarkson literary talent and Hammond’s book following his crash. Shame about what’s him name, the other one. But unfortunately it’s deteriorated into a programme for 5 year olds, embarrassingly pathetic and zero content if you want intelligent information about cars. In fact the comment above says it all, “entertaining”, yep like Coronation Street. If that’s want you want, good for you but I think the intelligent amongst us want an awful lot more.

]]> By: dzafer http://www.ededition.com/top-gear-versus-fifth-gear-which-british-car-show-is-better/comment-page-3/#comment-242271 dzafer Fri, 30 Sep 2011 07:01:07 +0000 http://www.ededition.com/top-gear-versus-fifth-gear-which-british-car-show-is-better/#comment-242271 top gear is the best hehehe no seriosly top gear is more more more more fun emision on tv.pozz dzafer top gear is the best hehehe no seriosly top gear is more more more more fun emision on tv.pozz dzafer

]]> By: kiran khatpe http://www.ededition.com/top-gear-versus-fifth-gear-which-british-car-show-is-better/comment-page-3/#comment-242164 kiran khatpe Sat, 27 Aug 2011 18:31:09 +0000 http://www.ededition.com/top-gear-versus-fifth-gear-which-british-car-show-is-better/#comment-242164 TOP GEAR is a much better show. TOP GEAR is a much better show.

]]> By: Chicawazza http://www.ededition.com/top-gear-versus-fifth-gear-which-british-car-show-is-better/comment-page-3/#comment-242093 Chicawazza Mon, 25 Jul 2011 10:04:41 +0000 http://www.ededition.com/top-gear-versus-fifth-gear-which-british-car-show-is-better/#comment-242093 Mate, who is the stig???!!!!! THE STIG is michael schumacher!!!!! hows THAT for racing credentials! TOP GEAR FOR LIFE!!!! Mate, who is the stig???!!!!! THE STIG is michael schumacher!!!!! hows THAT for racing credentials! TOP GEAR FOR LIFE!!!!

]]> By: rose http://www.ededition.com/top-gear-versus-fifth-gear-which-british-car-show-is-better/comment-page-3/#comment-242090 rose Sat, 23 Jul 2011 06:31:56 +0000 http://www.ededition.com/top-gear-versus-fifth-gear-which-british-car-show-is-better/#comment-242090 Top Gear is way better. I watch TG not for buying some cars, but for entertainment and a slight knowledge about cars only. TG's presenters are more entertaining and remarkable to watch too. Top Gear is way better. I watch TG not for buying some cars, but for entertainment and a slight knowledge about cars only. TG’s presenters are more entertaining and remarkable to watch too.

]]> By: Wicker http://www.ededition.com/top-gear-versus-fifth-gear-which-british-car-show-is-better/comment-page-3/#comment-242084 Wicker Sun, 17 Jul 2011 20:01:31 +0000 http://www.ededition.com/top-gear-versus-fifth-gear-which-british-car-show-is-better/#comment-242084 Top Gear is *probably* scripted? Top Gear is *probably* scripted?

]]> By: Teo http://www.ededition.com/top-gear-versus-fifth-gear-which-british-car-show-is-better/comment-page-3/#comment-241971 Teo Mon, 13 Jun 2011 21:35:12 +0000 http://www.ededition.com/top-gear-versus-fifth-gear-which-british-car-show-is-better/#comment-241971 Well I believe Top Gear is the more entertaining one. Fifth Gear is for people who only like cars and want to only talk about cars, while Top Gear get the fun side of cars and show it on TV. I really enjoy top gear and what they do is they present cars in an entertaining fasion. Well I believe Top Gear is the more entertaining one. Fifth Gear is for people who only like cars and want to only talk about cars, while Top Gear get the fun side of cars and show it on TV. I really enjoy top gear and what they do is they present cars in an entertaining fasion.

]]> By: Andy http://www.ededition.com/top-gear-versus-fifth-gear-which-british-car-show-is-better/comment-page-3/#comment-241892 Andy Sun, 15 May 2011 21:15:45 +0000 http://www.ededition.com/top-gear-versus-fifth-gear-which-british-car-show-is-better/#comment-241892 Fith Gear gives more of an oblective view on cars and I think is based more at reviewing cars that are more likely to be used by the general public. Top Gear is by far the best programme in terms of entertainment. Admitedly most of the cars reviewed are out of most peoples price range but even my wife who has no interest in cars finds the programme entertaining. Fith Gear gives more of an oblective view on cars and I think is based more at reviewing cars that are more likely to be used by the general public.

Top Gear is by far the best programme in terms of entertainment. Admitedly most of the cars reviewed are out of most peoples price range but even my wife who has no interest in cars finds the programme entertaining.

]]> By: mike http://www.ededition.com/top-gear-versus-fifth-gear-which-british-car-show-is-better/comment-page-3/#comment-241883 mike Thu, 12 May 2011 10:56:49 +0000 http://www.ededition.com/top-gear-versus-fifth-gear-which-british-car-show-is-better/#comment-241883 driving skill of the presenters should include the stig. If thats the case the likes of perry mccarthy and ben collins are infinetely more skilled than tiff and vicky driving skill of the presenters should include the stig. If thats the case the likes of perry mccarthy and ben collins are infinetely more skilled than tiff and vicky

]]> By: Benolds http://www.ededition.com/top-gear-versus-fifth-gear-which-british-car-show-is-better/comment-page-3/#comment-241837 Benolds Wed, 20 Apr 2011 10:13:32 +0000 http://www.ededition.com/top-gear-versus-fifth-gear-which-british-car-show-is-better/#comment-241837 I think The Stig would probably spell his name "The Stig" Not just... "stig" I agree though, Top Gear gets the trophy easy :) I think The Stig would probably spell his name “The Stig”
Not just… “stig”

I agree though, Top Gear gets the trophy easy :)

]]> By: stig http://www.ededition.com/top-gear-versus-fifth-gear-which-british-car-show-is-better/comment-page-3/#comment-241836 stig Mon, 18 Apr 2011 21:19:58 +0000 http://www.ededition.com/top-gear-versus-fifth-gear-which-british-car-show-is-better/#comment-241836 ...................... (What do you think I think) …………………. (What do you think I think)

]]> By: simon carroll http://www.ededition.com/top-gear-versus-fifth-gear-which-british-car-show-is-better/comment-page-3/#comment-241774 simon carroll Fri, 01 Apr 2011 16:44:00 +0000 http://www.ededition.com/top-gear-versus-fifth-gear-which-british-car-show-is-better/#comment-241774 Topgear is 100 percent better and the presenter are much better . Topgear is 100 percent better and the presenter are much better .

]]> By: Sapperpat http://www.ededition.com/top-gear-versus-fifth-gear-which-british-car-show-is-better/comment-page-3/#comment-241744 Sapperpat Sat, 19 Mar 2011 21:43:39 +0000 http://www.ededition.com/top-gear-versus-fifth-gear-which-british-car-show-is-better/#comment-241744 Top Gear may in fact be the best thing on television and I have 300 channels and billions of shows to choose from!!!! Top Gear may in fact be the best thing on television and I have 300 channels and billions of shows to choose from!!!!

]]> By: onur http://www.ededition.com/top-gear-versus-fifth-gear-which-british-car-show-is-better/comment-page-2/#comment-241697 onur Sat, 05 Mar 2011 13:53:57 +0000 http://www.ededition.com/top-gear-versus-fifth-gear-which-british-car-show-is-better/#comment-241697 Top Gear is more popular than Fifth Gear in Turkey.. Top Gear is more popular than Fifth Gear in Turkey..

]]>